Title: How Does Homer’s Odyssey Portray the Concept of Civilization versus Savagery
Author: MARTIN MUNYAO MUINDE
Email: ephantusmartin@gmail.com
Introduction
Homer’s Odyssey is not only a tale of adventure and homecoming but also a profound exploration of what it means to be civilized. Throughout the epic, Homer contrasts civilization and savagery to illustrate the values that define Greek society—hospitality, justice, respect for the gods, and moral order. The encounters that Odysseus experiences on his journey home from Troy serve as moral and cultural tests that reveal the tension between civilized behavior and barbaric impulses. Each episode, from the land of the Cyclopes to the Phaeacians’ palace, reflects the ancient Greek understanding of social harmony and human decency.
The contrast between civilization and savagery in The Odyssey underscores the importance of cultural identity and moral integrity. Civilization, for Homer, is characterized by respect for laws, hospitality, and divine authority, while savagery represents chaos, selfishness, and violence. Odysseus’ journey can thus be read as both a physical and moral voyage—a quest to restore order in a world where civilization is constantly threatened by barbarism. Through this lens, Homer’s epic becomes an enduring reflection on the values that sustain human society and distinguish it from moral corruption (Clarke, 2020).
Civilization and the Value of Hospitality (Xenia)
One of the most significant indicators of civilization in The Odyssey is xenia, the Greek code of hospitality. In ancient Greek culture, hospitality was considered a sacred duty governed by Zeus himself. Civilized societies in the epic, such as the Phaeacians and the home of Nestor, uphold this virtue by welcoming strangers with food, shelter, and respect. For instance, when Odysseus arrives at the court of King Alcinous, he is treated with kindness and generosity despite being a stranger (Homer, Odyssey, Book 7). This adherence to hospitality reflects moral refinement and the social order that defines civilization.
In contrast, the absence of xenia marks savagery and moral decay. The Cyclops Polyphemus, for example, represents the antithesis of civilization. He disregards hospitality, eats Odysseus’ men, and lives in isolation without laws or communal structure (Homer, Odyssey, Book 9). His barbaric behavior emphasizes the dangers of life outside civilization, where brute force replaces justice and moral reasoning. As Murnaghan (2011) notes, Homer uses the Cyclops episode to demonstrate that the essence of civilization lies in empathy and cooperation, not in physical power or self-sufficiency. Thus, xenia functions as a moral benchmark distinguishing the civilized from the savage in The Odyssey.
The Cyclopes and the Absence of Social Order
The Cyclopes are perhaps the most striking representation of savagery in The Odyssey. Their society lacks agriculture, government, and religion—features that, for the Greeks, defined a civilized community. Odysseus describes them as “lawless brutes who trust to the gods for nothing” (Homer, Odyssey, Book 9). They live in isolation, showing neither compassion nor cooperation. Polyphemus’ violence against Odysseus’ men symbolizes the primitive instincts that prevail when moral order collapses. His rejection of social norms mirrors the dangers of a world ungoverned by law or reverence for the divine (Nagy, 2013).
Odysseus’ victory over Polyphemus is not merely physical; it is intellectual and moral. By using his wit to blind the Cyclops and escape, Odysseus demonstrates that intelligence and social values triumph over brute force and savagery. This conflict between Odysseus and Polyphemus represents the broader tension between the civilized and the barbaric—the triumph of reason, diplomacy, and law over chaos and instinct. Homer’s portrayal of the Cyclopes thus reinforces the idea that civilization is founded on shared values, moral restraint, and rational thought (Austin, 2014).
The Phaeacians: A Model of Civilization
In stark contrast to the savagery of the Cyclopes, the Phaeacians represent the ideal of civilization in The Odyssey. Their society is governed by laws, religion, art, and hospitality. When Odysseus arrives on their island, he is received with generosity and respect. Queen Arete and King Alcinous embody compassion, order, and wisdom, providing Odysseus with the assistance he needs to return home (Homer, Odyssey, Book 8). The Phaeacians’ conduct reflects the Greek belief that a civilized society must balance material prosperity with moral and spiritual harmony.
The Phaeacians also symbolize the cultural ideals of cooperation and empathy. Their advanced seafaring and love of storytelling represent intellectual and artistic sophistication—qualities that separate them from barbaric societies. As Clarke (2020) observes, the Phaeacians’ kindness toward Odysseus highlights Homer’s vision of civilization as a space of moral responsibility and communal respect. Through their hospitality and reverence for divine order, the Phaeacians stand as a mirror of the world Odysseus strives to restore in Ithaca.
Savagery Within Ithaca: The Moral Decay of the Suitors
While many of Odysseus’ trials occur in foreign lands, Homer also depicts savagery within Ithaca itself through the behavior of the suitors. These men, who exploit Odysseus’ absence by feasting on his wealth and courting Penelope, embody moral corruption within the civilized world. Although they live within a structured society, their greed, arrogance, and disrespect for divine and social laws mark them as savages in spirit. Their actions violate xenia, transforming Odysseus’ home into a space of moral disorder (Homer, Odyssey, Book 21).
The suitors’ downfall symbolizes the restoration of civilization through justice and moral order. Odysseus’ return and punishment of the suitors reestablish the balance between human law and divine will. As Murnaghan (2011) explains, Homer uses this episode to demonstrate that savagery is not confined to foreign lands—it can emerge within civilization when people abandon moral restraint and social responsibility. Thus, the cleansing of Ithaca represents the triumph of civilized values over internal corruption and moral chaos.
The Role of the Gods in Defining Civilization
The gods play a crucial role in distinguishing civilization from savagery throughout The Odyssey. Civilized societies are depicted as those that honor the gods and seek their guidance, while barbaric characters defy divine authority. Odysseus’ piety and humility earn him divine protection from Athena, whereas Polyphemus’ defiance of Zeus invites punishment. This connection between divine reverence and moral order emphasizes that civilization is not merely a human construct but a sacred responsibility (Homer, Odyssey, Book 13).
Moreover, the gods themselves act as enforcers of justice, ensuring that moral balance is maintained. Athena’s intervention in Odysseus’ journey represents divine endorsement of civilization and wisdom over chaos. According to Nagy (2013), Homer’s portrayal of divine justice reflects the ancient Greek belief that a civilized life requires harmony between human reason and divine will. The gods’ involvement in the restoration of Ithaca thus reaffirms that civilization thrives where moral and spiritual order coexist.
Conclusion
Homer’s Odyssey portrays civilization and savagery as moral opposites that define the human experience. Through encounters with the Cyclopes, the Phaeacians, and the suitors, Homer explores the qualities that distinguish civilized life—hospitality, justice, piety, and self-restraint—from the barbaric forces of greed, violence, and chaos. Odysseus’ journey symbolizes the struggle to uphold these values in a world where savagery constantly threatens order.
Ultimately, The Odyssey celebrates the triumph of intellect, morality, and divine harmony over brutality and anarchy. Homer’s nuanced depiction of civilization serves as both a cultural reflection and a timeless moral lesson: a truly civilized society is defined not by its power or wealth, but by its compassion, order, and respect for divine and human law. Through Odysseus’ trials, Homer reminds readers that civilization is not merely a condition of life—it is a continuous moral choice.
References
-
Austin, N. (2014). Homeric Soundings: The Shaping of the Epic Song. University of California Press.
-
Clarke, M. (2020). Fate, Agency, and Moral Responsibility in Homer’s Odyssey. Oxford University Press.
-
Homer. (1996). The Odyssey (R. Fagles, Trans.). Penguin Classics.
-
Murnaghan, S. (2011). Disguise and Recognition in The Odyssey. Princeton University Press.
-
Nagy, G. (2013). The Ancient Greek Hero in 24 Hours. Harvard University Press.